| Theatres re-open – The Crescent temporarily becomes Garrison Theatre |
| 1941 | She Had to Do Something | Sean O’Faolain | Hester Rosser |
| Biography | S. N. Behrman | Eric Knight |
| 1942 | On Life’s Sunny Side | Belge Krog | Norman Leaker |
| The Magistrate | Sir Arthur Pinero | Marston Goulcher |
| The Gentle People | Irwin Shaw | Hester Rosser |
| The Dear Departed / Birds of a Feather / Red Peppers | Stanley Houghton / J. O. Francis / Noel Coward | Gwen Muspratt / Reuben Dorey / Marston Goulcher |
| 1943 | Crescentricities | Various | Marston Goulcher |
| I Killed the Count | Alec Coppel | Reuben Dorey |
| Ladies in Retirement | Edward Pearcy and Reginald Denham | Isabel Harper |
| Garrison Revue | Various | Marston Goulcher |
| Laburnum Grove | J. B. Priestley | Hester Rosser |
| Gaslight | Patrick Hamilton | Marston Goulcher |
| 1944 | Full House | Ivor Novello | Marston Goulcher |
| Tobias and the Angel | James Bridie | Isabel Harper |
| Lover’s Leap | Philip Johnson | Marston Goulcher |
| Mr. Pim Passes By | A. A. Milne | Phyl Grove |
| The Light of Heart | Emlyn Williams | Sam Johnson |
| 1945 | La Parisienne | Henri Becque | Isabel Harper |
| The Old Ladies | Rodney Ackland | Lionel Dunn |
| George and Margaret | Gerald Savory | Elaine Seale |
| The Mulberry Trees | Basil Thomas | Norman Leaker |
| Post-war, the Crescent Theatre re-opens as normal |
| Tobias and the Angel | James Bridie | Isabel Harper |
| The Rising Sun | Hermann Heijermans | Elaine Seale |
| The Government Inspector | Nikolai Gogol | Lionel Dunn |
| 1946 | The Comedian | Henri Gheon | Sam Johnson |
| Shadow and Substance | Paul Vincent Carroll | Marston Goulcher |
| Saint Joan | George Bernard Shaw | Normal Leaker |
| Painted Sparrows | Guy Paxton & Edward V. Hoile | Marston Goulcher |
| Of Mice and Men | John Steinbeck | Norman Leaker |
| The Mask and the Face | Chester Bailey Fernald | Sam Johnson |
| 1947 | Ghosts | Henrik Ibsen | Norman Leaker |
| The Shining Hour | Keith Winter | Marston Goulcher |
| Golden Boy | Clifford Odets | Sam Johnson |
| Wind of Heaven | Emlyn Williams | Marston Goulcher |
| Henry IV Part 2 | William Shakespeare | Normal Leaker |
| Mungo’s Mansion | Walter Macken | Walter Dalby |
| 1948 | The Father | August Strindberg | Sam Johnson |
| Barbara’s Wedding | Sir James Barrie | Sam Johnson |
| Father Malachy’s Miracle | Brian Doherty | Frank Jones |
| Thunder Rock | Robert Ardrey | Gladys Joiner |
| The Queen’s Husband | Robert E. Sherwood | Marston Goulcher |
| The Typewriter | Jean Cocteau | Gladys Joiner |
| The Way of the World | William Congreve | Joan Simpson |
| 1949 | The Land of the Living | Leonard Irwin | Norman Leaker |
| Martine | Jean-Jacques Bernard | Rex Sargeant |
| Now Barabbas | William Douglas Home | Marston Goulcher |
| The Imaginary Invalid | J. P. Moliere | Roy Malcolm |
| The Devil to Pay | Dorothy L. Sayers | Arthur Taylor |
| Trelawney of the Wells | Arthur Wing Pinero | |