| 1960 | The Three Sisters | Anton Chekhov | Morris Fishman |
| The Captive Land | J. Garcia Lorca | Edwin Lilley |
| The Hamlet of Stepney Green | Bernard Kops | Morris Fishman |
| Juno and the Paycock | Sean O’Casey | Brian J. Burton |
| 1961 | Second Saint of Cyprus | George Weller | Brian J. Burton |
| On Approval | Frederick Lonsdale | Frank Jones |
| Saint’s Day | John Whiting | Edwin Lilley |
| The Chinese Lantern (Crescent Youth Theatre) | Laurence Housman | Margaret Gilmour Parker |
| The Country Wife | William Wycherley | Pauline Smith |
| Odd Man In | Claude Magnier | Pauline Smith |
| Serjeant Musgrave’s Dance | John Arden | George Harrison |
| The Wood Demon | Anton Chekhov | Morris Fishman |
| Rape of the Belt | Benn Levy | John Taylor |
| Five Finger Exercise | Peter Shaffer | Pauline Smith |
| Dandy Dick | Arthur W. Pinero | Frank Jones |
| 1962 | The Wrong Side of the Park | John Mortimer | John Taylor |
| Orpheus Descending | Tennessee Williams | Edwin Lilley |
| Cheerio Lou | Leonard Webb | Pauline Smith |
| Sweeney Todd the Barber | Brian J. Burton | John Taylor |
| Loves Labours Lost | William Shakespeare | Pauline Smith |
| The Complaisant Lover | Graham Greene | Edwin Lilley |
| A Woman of No Importance | Oscar Wilde | Lilian Fletcher |
| 1963 | Night Season | Kenneth Hill | Kenneth Hill |
| School for Wives | Moliere, translated by M. Screech | Barbara Morgan |
| Night Out | Harold Pinter | Kenneth Hill |
| Guilt Transferred | Ivor Jay | Margaret Gilbert |
| Lunch Hour | John Mortimer | Ronald Barber |
| The Chinese Wall | Max Frisch | Morris Fishman |
| A Midsummer Night’s Dream | William Shakespeare | Margaret Gilmore Parker |
| The Lady from the Sea | Henrik Ibsen | Pauline Smith |
| Man and Superman | George Bernard Shaw | Frank Jones |
| The Three Cavaliers | Beverley Cross | Kenneth Hill |
| 1964 | Toys in the Attic | Lilian Hellman | Ronald Barber |
| Hamlet | William Shakespeare | Edwin Lilley |
| Under the Sycamore Tree | Samuel Spewack | Brian Hulme |
| Songs and Sonnets | William Shakespeare | Thelma A. M. Bennitt |
| The Beaux Strategem | George Farquar | George Harrison |
| Crescent Theatre Company moves to new site on Cumberland Street |
| Children to Bless Us | Andre Roussin | Edwin Lilley |
| All My Sons | Arthur Miller | Pauline Smith |
| 1965 | Drum Beat | Kenneth Hill | Ron Barber |
| The Queen and the Rebels | Ugo Betti | Judith Mackay |
| Thieves’ Carnival | Jean Anouilh | Kenneth Hill |
| The Caucasian Chalk Circle | Bertolt Brecht, translated by James and Tania Stern with W. H. Auden | Anthony Cornish |
| My Three Angels | Sam and Bella Spewack | Pamela Trethowan |
| Private Lives | Noel Coward | Brian J. Burton |
| Tiger at the Gates | Jean Giraudoux | Charles A. Butler |
| The Cocktail Party | T. S. Eliot | Pamela Trethowan |
| 1966 | The Wings of the Dove | Christopher Taylor | Ron Barber |
| King Lear | William Shakespeare | Brian J. Burton |
| Catback | Nick McCarty | Andrew Cornwall |
| Picnic | William Inge | Kenneth Hill |
| The Waltz of the Toreadors | Jean Anouilh | Kenneth Hill |
| The Birthday Party | Harold Pinter | Brian Hulme |
| Platonov | Anton Chekhov | Ron Barber |
| 1967 | The Poker Session | Hugh Leonard | Brian J. Burton |
| Antony and Cleopatra | William Shakespeare | Anthony Cornish |
| A Lily in Little India | Donald Howarth | Edwin Lilley |
| The Imaginary Invalid | Moliere, translated by Bert Briscoe | Bert Briscoe |
| Billy Liar | Keith Waterhouse and Willis Hall | Bert Briscoe |
| The Devils | John Whiting | Edwin Lilley |
| Doctors of Philosophy | Muriel Spark | Barbara Morgan |
| The Murder of Maria Marten or The Red Barn | Brian J. Burton | Bryn Davies |
| 1968 | The Homecoming | Harold Pinter | Ron Barber |
| Troilus and Cressida | William Shakespeare | Anthony Cornish |
| The Lasting Tune | Michala Crees | Brian J. Burton |
| The Night of the Iguana | Tennessee Williams | Kenneth Hill |
| You Never Can Tell | George Bernard Shaw | Allen Weston |
| Ring Around the Moon | Jean Anouilh | Ron Barber |
| She Stoops to Conquer | Oliver Goldsmith | Bert Briscoe |
| Desire Under the Elms | Eugene O’Neill | Kenneth Hill |
| 1969 | Thark | Ben Travers | Frank Jones |
| Marat/Sade | Peter Weiss | Paul Clements |
| Say Who You Are | Keith Waterhouse and Willis Hall | Kenneth Hill |
| Rhinoceros | Eugene Ionesco | Richard Drinkwater |
| The Clouds of Aristophanes | Aristophanes, translated by Nick Alldridge | Anthony Cornish |
| The Lady’s Not For Burning | Christopher Fry | Bert Briscoe |
| The Importance of Being Earnest | Oscar Wilde | Ron Barber |
| Loot | Joe Orton | Jim Duckett |
| Cinderella | Adapted by Kenneth Hill | Kenneth Hill |