| 1990 | The Wind in the Willows | Willis Hall and Denis King | Keith Harris |
| Canterbury Tales | Phil Woods | John Round |
| Camille | Pam Gems | Euan C. Rose |
| One for the Road | Willy Russell | Bryn Davies |
| The Knight of the Burning Pestle (Crescent Youth Theatre) | Francis Beaumont | Claire Cochrane |
| Pravda | Howard Brenton and David Hare | Andrew Cowie |
| The Threepenny Opera | Bertolt Brecht and Kurt Weill | Alan K. Marshall |
| Much Ado About Nothing | William Shakespeare | Bryn Davies |
| Table Manners | Alan Ayckbourn | Stephen Hollander |
| Private Lives | Noel Coward | Sheila Carradine |
| Dr. Faustus | Christopher Marlowe | Alan K Marshall |
| Gaslight and Garters | Michael Barry | Michael Barry |
| Christmas Wassail | Various | Gary Spruce and Bryn Davies |
| The Wizard of Oz | Frank Gabrielson, Harold Arlen and E. Y. Harburg | Keith Harris |
| 1991 | Rebecca | Daphne du Maurier | Stephen Downing |
| One of Us | Robin Chapman | Patty MacGregor |
| Teechers (Crescent Youth Theatre) | John Godber | Bryn Davies |
| Amadeus | Peter Shaffer | Michael Barry |
| Top Girls | Caryl Churchill | Claire Cochrane |
| A Madhouse in Goa | Martin Sherman | Janet Grant |
| The Farndale Avenue Housing Estate Townswomen’s Guild Dramatic Society’s Production of Macbeth | David MacGillivray and Walter Zerlin Jr. | Brian J. Burton |
| War and Peace | Leo Tolstoy | Ronald Barber |
| Gotcha | Barrie O’Keefe | Carolyn Scott-Jeffs |
| The Rivals | R. B. Sheridan | George Harrison |
| Happy Families | John Godber | Keith Harris |
| The Murder of Maria Marten or The Red Barn | Brian J. Burton | Brian J. Burton |
| Peter Pan | J. M. Barrie | Ian Thompson |
| Christmas Wassail | Various | Gary Spruce and Bryn Davies |
| 1992 | Wuthering Heights | Emily Brontë | Sheila Carradine |
| The Tempest | William Shakespeare | Alan K. Marshall |
| Hard Times (Crescent Youth Theatre) | Charles Dickens, adapted by Stephen Jeffreys | Claire Cochrane |
| Clownmaker | Richard Crane | Ronald Barber |
| Guys and Dolls | Frank Loesser, Jo Swerling and Abe Burrows | Stephen Downing |
| Lettice and Lovage | Peter Shaffer | Ronald Barber |
| Whose Life Is It Anyway | Brian Clarke | Gerard Lucas |
| Speed of the Plow | David Mamet | Vernon Hicks |
| Loot | Joe Orton | Janet Grant |
| A Midsummer Night’s Dream | William Shakespeare | Bryn Davies |
| Abigail’s Party | Mike Leigh | Carolyn Scott-Jeffs |
| The Taming of the Shrew | William Shakespeare | Claire Cochrane |
| The Secret of Sherlock Holmes | Jeremy Paul | Sheila Carradine |
| Our Country’s Good / The Recruiting Officer | Timberlake Wertenbaker / George Farquhar | Alan K. Marshall |
| Barefoot in the Park | Neil Simon | Patty MacGregor |
| Christmas Wassail | Various | Gary Spruce and Charles Fulford |
| Cinderella | John Gilder and Alan Crocker | Ian Thompson |
| 1993 | Dracula is Undead and Well and Living in Purfleet | Charles McKeown | Stephen Downing |
| The Vortex | Noel Coward | Ronald Barber |
| I’d Rather Charleston | Janet Grant and Gary Spruce | Janet Grant and Gary Spruce |
| Dark of the Moon (Crescent Youth Theatre) | Howard Richardson and William Berney | Margaret MacDonald |
| Steel Magnolias | Robert Harling | Carolyn Scott-Jeffs |
| The Lark | Jean Anouilh | Bert Briscoe |
| A Chorus for Disapproval | Alan Ayckbourn | Euan C. Rose |
| The Ghost Train | Arnold Ridley | David Heptonstall |
| Bouncers | John Godber | Sue Downing |
| Twelfth Night | William Shakespeare | Andrew Cowie |
| Touched | Stephen Lowe | Carolyn Scott-Jeffs |
| Pygmalion | George Bernard Shaw | David Heptonstall |
| Gaslight and Garters | Michael Barry | Michael Barry |
| Jack and the Beanstalk | Charles Fulford, Janet Grant and Ian Thompson | Noel Alexander |
| Christmas Wassail | Various | Gary Spruce and Charles Fulford |
| 1994 | Pride and Prejudice | Jane Austen, adapted by Brian J. Burton | Ronald Barber |
| St Joan of the Stockyards (Crescent Youth Theatre) | Bertolt Brecht | Claire Cochrane |
| Restoration | Edward Bond | Alan Fraser |
| Charlie and the Chocolate Factory | Roald Dahl | Alan K. Marshall |
| Stags and Hens | Willy Russell | Carolyn Scott-Jeffs |
| Cabaret | John Kander and Fred Ebb | Alan K. Marshall |
| Entertaining Mr. Sloane | Joe Orton | Michael Barry |
| The Merry Wives of Windsor | William Shakespeare | Ian Thompson |
| September in the Rain | John Godber | Gerard Lucas |
| The Woman Who Cooked Her Husband | Debbie Isitt | Stephen Message |
| Betrayal | Harold Pinter | Stewart Snape |
| The Comedy of Errors | William Shakespeare | Claire Cochrane |
| Old Time Music Hall | Michael Barry | Michael Barry |
| The Sleeping Beauty | David Cregan and Brian Protheroe | Karen Crouch |
| Christmas Wassail | Various | Gary Spruce and Anne O’Neil |
| 1995 | Les Liaisons Dangereuses | Christopher Hampton | Carolyn Scott-Jeffs |
| Death of a Salesman | Arthur Miller | Margaret MacDonald |
| Blood Brothers / Ernie’s Incredible Illucinations (Crescent Youth Theatre) | Alan Ayckbourn / Willy Russell | Ashley Pearce |
| The Snatching of Horrible Harold | John Gardner and Fizz Coleman | Colin Judges |
| Yerma | Frederico Garcia Lorca | Patty MacGregor |
| Sweeney Todd | Stephen Sondheim | Andrew Cowie |
| Daisy Pulls It Off | Denise Deegan | Sue Downing |
| A Man For All Seasons | Robert Bolt | Sheila Carradine |
| Play It Again Sam | Woody Allen | Gerard Lucas |
| Death and the Maiden | Ariel Dorfman | Stephen Donovan |
| Victoria Station / After Magritte | Harold Pinter / Tom Stoppard | Jo Burrill |
| Racing Demon | David Hare | Ronald Barber |
| Nasty Neighbours | Debbie Isitt | Michael Barry |
| Kiss of the Spiderwoman | Manuel Puig, translated by Alan Baker | Carolyn Scott-Jeffs |
| A Doll’s House | Henrik Ibsen | Karen Crouch |
| Christmas Wassail | Various | Gary Spruce and Anne O’Neil |
| The Snow Queen | Stuart Paterson | Alan K. Marshall |
| 1996 | Time of My Life | Alan Ayckbourn | Stewart Snape |
| Serjeant Musgrave’s Dance | John Arden | Norman Thackwray |
| Hiawatha (Crescent Youth Theatre) | Michael Bogdanov | Jonathan Cochrane |
| The Bear / The Proposal | Anton Chekhov | Robert Ball |
| The Beggar’s Opera | John Gay | Carolyn Scott-Jeffs |
| The BFG | Roald Dahl, adapted by David Wood | Ian Thompson |
| It’s a Wonderful Life | Ronald Barber | Ronald Barber |
| Cold Comfort Farm | Stella Gibbons/ Paul Dourst | Euan C. Rose |
| The Last Yankee | Arthur Miller | Colin Judges |
| The Taming of the Shrew | William Shakespeare | John Round |
| Educating Rita | Willy Russell | Russ Fyles |
| A Woman of No Importance | Oscar Wilde | Ian Thompson |
| Come Back to the Five and Dime, Jimmy Dean, Jimmy Dean | Ed Graczyck | Jo Thackwray |
| Christmas Wassail | Various | Gary Spruce & Dave Hill |
| A Christmas Carol | Charles Dickens, adpated by John Mortimer | Karen Crouch |
| Gaslight and Garters | Margaret MacDonald and Fiona Cotton | Margaret MacDonald and Fiona Cotton |
| 1997 | Happy Days | Samuel Beckett | Colin Judges |
| La Musica / The Maids | Marguerite Dumas / Jean Genet | Stewart Snape/ Stephen Donovan |
| Romeo and Juliet (Crescent Youth Theatre) | William Shakespeare | Claire Cochrane |
| A Taste of Honey | Shelagh Delaney | Carolyn Scott-Jeffs |
| A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum | Stephen Sondheim, Burt Shevelove and Larry Gelbert | Alan K. Marshall |
| Jane Eyre | Charlotte Bronte, adapted by Fay Weldon | Andrew Cowie |
| The Madness of George III | Alan Bennett | Euan C Rose |
| A Midsummer Night’s Dream | William Shakespeare | Michael Barry |
| An Evening With Gary Lineker | Arthur Smith and Chris England | Gerard Lucas |
| All My Sons | Arthur Miller | Colin Judges |
| Talking Heads | Alan Bennett | |
| Wyrd Sisters | Terry Pratchett | Norman Thackwray |
| Christmas Wassail | Various | Gary Spruce and Dave Hill |
| Aladdin | Charles Fulford, Janet Grant, Ken Simpson and Ian Thompson | Stephen Downing |
| Gaslight and Garters | Margaret MacDonald and Fiona Cotton | Margaret MacDonald and Fiona Cotton |
| 1998 | Shakers | John Godber and Jane Thornton | Jo Thackwray |
| Ghosts | Henrik Ibsen | Stewart Snape |
| Kennedy’s Children | Robert Patrick | Colin Judges |
| The Pirates of Penzance (Crescent Youth Theatre) | W. S. Gilbert and Arthur Sullivan | David Williams |
| Gypsy | Jule Styne and Stephen Sondheim | Alan K. Marshall |
| As You Like It | William Shakespeare | John Round |
| Design for Living | Noel Coward | Ronald Barber |
| Crescent Theatre Company moves to current site on Sheepcote Street |
| An Ideal Husband | Oscar Wilde | Michael Barry |
| Tom and Viv | Michael Hastings | Norman Thackwray |
| The Birmingham Seven | Yvonne Lambert | Hugh Blackwood |
| Gasping | Ben Elton | Gerard Lucas |
| Christmas Wassail | Various | Gary Spruce and Dave Hill |
| Dick Whittington | Sue Downing | Karen Crouch |
| 1999 | Frankie and Tommy | Garry Lyons | Sharon Fyles |
| Mort | Terry Pratchett | Ian Thompson |
| Noel and Gertie | Sheridan Morley | Janet Grant |
| Teechers (Crescent Youth Theatre) | John Godber | Dani Parr |
| Bus Stop | William Inge | Jo Thackwray |
| The Crucible | Arthur Miller | Stephen Downing |
| The Cemetery Club | Ivan Menchell | Bert Briscoe |
| The Phantom of the Opera | Ken Hill | Alan K. Marshall |
| Dead Funny | Terry Johnson | Euan C. Rose |
| When We Are Married | J. B. Priestley | Sheila Carradine |
| Oleanna | David Mamet | Colin Judges |
| The Importance of Being Earnest | Oscar Wilde | Ronald Barber |
| Present Laughter | Noel Coward | Jo Thackwray |
| The Rise and Fall of Little Voice | Jim Cartwright | Ian Thompson |
| It Started With a Kiss | John Godber | Stephen Downing |
| The Chrysalids / Get Well Soon / Victoria Station (Crescent Youth Theatre) | John Wyndham/ Ken Cambell / Harold Pinter | Gerard Lucas |
| August | Julian Mitchell | Colin Judges |
| The School for Scandal | R. B. Sheridan | Norman Thackwray |
| My Life In Art | Andrew Cowie | Andrew Cowie |
| Christmas Wassail | Various | Gary Spruce and Dave Hill |